Pros and cons of dating an athlete. If you need some advice about dating and maintaining a relationship with an athlete. Unfortunately, dating an athlete can come with its downsides, so we spoke with a college girl, let's call her Danielle, who's been dating a. Tips For Dating An Athlete From A Non-Athletic Perspective 1. Attending the games, tournaments, and award ceremonies are a MUST. 2. Acquiring some knowledge of the sport will help you understand the struggles and triumphs. 3. You are now their personal Masseuse. They will always be sore.